top of page

The Effect of Slashing Impact Fees

12 minutes ago
3 min read

Xavier Becerra said he would “slash” impact fees, or did he?


Realtor.com claimed (after the election):


In the run-up to the recent election, Xavier Becerra, a former congressman, made housing one of the main pillars of his campaign, promising to declare a housing-shortage state of emergency on his very first day in office and appoint senior officials across state agencies who will be tasked with removing obstacles to construction projects. 


Becerra’s ambitious platform includes proposals to enforce 90-day "shot clocks" for building permits to accelerate construction, slash impact fees, streamline reviews for modular homes, and overhaul financing for affordable housing.


Looking ahead, Xu expects Becerra to face significant hurdles, beginning with potential legal challenges and pushbacks on the housing front.


"For example, his plan targets lower impact fees, but some cities rely heavily on those fees to pay for infrastructure, and his campaign has not detailed how that lost revenue would be replaced," notes the economist. "A clearer plan for cities will be needed to win their cooperation." (Realtor.com, Snejana Farberov)."


In fairness, there are various sites that claim that Becerra said he would slash development impact fees and a number of sites that claim he never said that.


Development Impact Fees (DIFs) have often become the target for reducing the cost of a home, probably due to the fact that the average person has absolutely no understanding of what they are and why they are needed. Often incorrectly referred to as a tax, they qualify as a fee simply because they represent the cost of expanding the Agency’s capital infrastructure necessary to extend services to new homes and business structures. That infrastructure includes (but is not necessarily limited to): public safety stations, emergency response vehicles and specialty equipment for police and fire, streets, signals and bridges, storm water collection and storage facilities, water treatment facilities, distribution lines, pumps, storage facilities (tanks), sewer collection lines and treatment facilities, libraries, community centers, aquatic facilities and parkland and parks.


Because of this, it would be extremely shortsighted to administratively “slash” impact fees. The result would not be what people would expect. Impact Fees are allowed and described in Government Code §66000 and are considered to be a local government revenue source needed to off-set the cost of the one-time capital infrastructure needed to support new development.  Even Realtor.com recognizes the importance of DIFs.


If the governor-elect were to take action to slash impact fees, he would have to find a suitable replacement for what would then become an unfunded government mandate. This argument is based upon the concept that there are revenues dedicated to local government needs as evidenced by a number of restrictions, primarily Proposition 22. Prop 22 (passed in 2010), bans state raids on local government tax revenues, such as local property, lodging or sales taxes.  This allows cities, counties, and special districts to be able to rely on said property taxes, local sales and business taxes, user fees, and state allocations.


There is no revenue source that could replace DIFs and it’s a bit specious to artificially reduce them. I can think of one city that identified over $1.0 billion in public infrastructure necessary to serve, in effect, a doubling of their existing 250,000 population city. The State would never be able to replace that amount.


If DIFs were slashed in any fashion, large scale residential development would come to a screeching halt because public agencies would no longer be in a position to approve private development were they not able to acquire greatly needed infrastructure needed to serve that same development.  In short, slashing DIFs would work against the Governor-elect’s mission to ramp up additional housing (over current rates one would assume), and I think he’s aware of that. So, I wouldn’t worry too much, but I would keep my eyes open too.


Lastly, housing prices are based on market conditions. So, if a home can be sold for $600,000 and the impact fees are then reduced by, say, $25,000, the house will sell for, drumroll please, $600,000 and not for $575,000.  It would just give developers a bigger profit.

Recent Posts

See All
Framing Fee Increases

Success in having fee recommendations adopted will often be dependent on how well you can “frame” the issues in a way that “speaks” to your audience. The goal of this article is to assist you in frami

 
 
 
Just Be Yourself and Don't Compare

This issue is still especially relevant, so we are re-running an article from a few years ago. The more things change, the more they stay the same. In just about every project we work on our client

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page